Sir Arthur Conan Doyle | Healing, Hell, and the History of American Insane Asylums

Image from Doyle’s Story, The Creeping Man

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes stories illustrate several Victorian ideas about insanity and its causes (see last post). In “The Adventure of the Naval Treaty,” Doyle described a case of acute mania which was resolved with prompt and proper care–an entirely understandable outcome. However, with “The Creeping Man,” Doyle’s understanding of the external causes of human behavior seems to be completely awry.

In this mystery from 1923, Professor Presbury’s personal secretary tells Holmes and Watson about his employer’s peculiar changes in behavior. Holmes eventually discovers the bizarre reason for the professor’s changed behavior: Presbury started to behave like a monkey because in a quest for youth, he began using a serum obtained from monkey blood/glands. This serum has given him the animal’s traits.

Insane Asylum at Kankakee

The idea behind this story sounds ridiculous, but Doyle may have been taking a cue from real events. In 1899, the New York Times had reported on Irwin Fuller Bush, a young man considered hopelessly insane and admitted to the Insane Asylum at Kankakee (Illinois). He had been almost miraculously restored to health by Dr. B. P. Roberts, a physician in Greene City, Missouri who treated Bush with animal glands. Roberts said, “Today, through the treatment with lymph from glands of goats, Bush is at home and declared to be completely restored in mind.”

Meeting of the Medical Staff, Kankakee Mental Hospital, circa 1910

The glands were also said to “arrest senility.” Roberts was enthusiastic enough about his treatment to go to Europe and try to convince alienists there to adopt the treatment in their own insane asylums. This real-life event and others using animal glands to cure various ailments, simply reflected the medical community’s imperfect understanding of what caused physical and mental changes in people.

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

Though modern readers can find old treatments for mental health laughable, they made sense to a generation just beginning to move away from even more archaic thought on the topic. Victorian-era conceptions about “madness” are wonderfully illustrated in Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes stories. Doyle had a medical degree (University of Edinburgh, 1881) and had practiced medicine before writing these mysteries, so his presentation of mental illness and its causes likely reflected his own, educated views on it.

Rather than look at madness as a permanent state deriving from physical roots, newer thought allowed for events like shock, overwork, and stress to precipitate bouts of insanity that could hopefully prove temporary if given correct–and timely–care. This idea played out well in “The Adventure of the Naval Treaty.” In the narrative, a young man in a trusted position lost valuable papers and felt himself ruined over it. He tells Holmes and Watson that upon trying to go home after his discovery: “I had a fit in the [train] station, and before we reached home I was practically a raving maniac.”

Illustration from Doyle’s Story Concerning Temporary Madness

Woman Admitted to Bedlam Hospital for Acute Mania, courtesy The Sun

He went on to tell the two that he had been “raving with brain fever” for nine weeks, but that with the tender care of his fiance and doctor, he had just recovered his reason. This episode clearly fit the modern idea that shocks and emotional turmoil could cause insanity–and that so-called acute (recent/short) episodes of insanity, if acted upon quickly, could be cured.

Healing, Hell, and the History of American Insane Asylums

The History of Insane Asylums

Tag Archives: Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

Sherlock Again

Writing Madness