Alienist Dr. Isaac Ray

People today wonder how physicians and other educated people could have believed excessive smoking, masturbation, or reading novels might lead to insanity. Though anything in excess is probably not as healthy for a person as that same thing in moderation, how could something like “excessive study” cause insanity? An extremely prominent alienist, Dr. Isaac Ray, explained:

“Though hard study at school is rarely the immediate cause of insanity, it is the most frequent of its ulterior causes, except hereditary tendencies.” Ray further declared that the chances of recovery [from insanity] were far fewer in the “studious, intellectual child” than in the opposite type. The reason for this, Ray explained, was that “though the immediate mischief may have seemed slight, but the brain is left in a condition of peculiar impressibility, which renders it morbidly sensitive to every adverse influence.”

Students From Glen Eden Boarding School for Girls, circa 1911

Ray’s remarks appeared in a September, 1859 issue of the The Atlantic Monthly, within an article strongly admonishing the then-present system of excessive schoolwork for children. A typical schedule in a well-run girls’ boarding school could be something like this: Rise at 5:00 a.m., study for two hours, eat breakfast, spend six more hours in the schoolroom, eat lunch, then spend two hours sewing, writing letters, completing other small tasks, and perhaps walking if weather permitted. Afterward there would be another hour of study, supper, and then two more hours of study–eleven in all. The author later mentioned popular Sunday School contests throughout the country, in which winners memorized up to 5,000 Bible verses.

An 1854 Math Book by Joseph Ray

It’s no wonder that many children fell into ill health, whether or not the excessive study actually led to insanity. However, with this kind of tasking in mind, it’s a bit easier to believe the (unnamed) author’s statement that he had recently heard of “a child’s dying insane, from sheer overwork, and raving of algebra.”