Tag Archives: Blackwell’s Island

Could Anyone Be Cured Here?

New York City Asylum for the Insane, Men, Ward's Island

New York City Asylum for the Insane, Men, Ward’s Island

Conditions for newly-arrived immigrants judged to be insane (see last post) were dismal. The emigrant hospital on Ward’s Island was completely inadequate, and it was discontinued after only a few years. New York’s insane population (immigrants included) continued to be housed on these islands, however, and even the most oblivious visitor must have seen that it would be nearly impossible to cure any patient under the conditions there.

“The overcrowding on Blackwell’s Island, even after 400 male patients had been transferred to Ward’s Island, was unbelievable,” says one writer (either a Dr. Parson or Dr. Rowe, who both contributed to a history of New York’s insane asylums). “Not less than 400 beds were made up nightly on the floor.”

Women Eating at Bellvue Hospital, Blackwell's Island, circa 1896, courtesy Museum of the City of New York. 93.1.1.4918

Women Eating at Bellevue Hospital, Blackwell’s Island, circa 1896, courtesy Museum of the City of New York. 93.1.1.4918

Ward’s Island sounds even worse. There were too few attendants, too little food and clothing, inadequate seating–and so few common necessities that patients often had to eat with their fingers. “Nights were hideous with noises and profanity,” the doctor continues. “Patients were locked in their rooms . . . straw-filled ticks, reeking and filthy, lay heaped about. Nurses were unknown and the attendants were coarse and inexperienced.”

The litany of failures went on and on. Of course, no one who could get a better job wanted to work there, and the city was forced to hire convicts as attendants. One can only imagine how these employees “managed” their patients. Finally, a new superintendent in charge worked energetically on the patients’ behalf, and conditions began to change.

Crowded Dining on Blackwell's Island, circa 1896, courtesy Viewing NYC.com

Crowded Dining on Blackwell’s Island, circa 1896, courtesy Viewing NYC.com

My final post on this topic will detail some of the new superintendent’s work.

Dangerous Confinement

Harper's New Monthly Magazine, 1866, Showed A Doctor Making His Rounds at Blackwell's Island Lunatic Asylum

Harper’s New Monthly Magazine, 1866, Showed A Doctor Making His Rounds at Blackwell’s Island Lunatic Asylum

The attendants working in insane asylums often had deservedly poor reputations. However, many were dedicated and capable, and performed their duties admirably. We can only imagine the outcome of any number of harrowing situations if attendants had not remained calm and committed to the people who depended on them.

An article in an 1879 issue of the New York Times reported on a fire that had broken out in a large building beside the main asylum on Blackwell’s Island. The building held about 100 female patients, who were locked in rows of cells on each floor. Smoke began pouring out of the cellar late in the evening and attendants gave the alarm. The Medical Superintendent had them unlock each cell and release the patients, but getting them outside to safety could have been quite a task given the unusual circumstances and mental state of the patients.

An Asylum Dance at Blackwell's Island

An Asylum Dance at Blackwell’s Island

However, to calm patients’ fear and excitement, the attendants told the women “there was to be a dance in the Amusement Hall, a building in which concerts and balls were given to the inmates of the asylum,” the paper reported.

The patients exited via fire escapes, and to keep up the pretense that all was well, someone played “a merry air” on the piano in the Amusement Hall. Some of the patients began to dance on the lawn as employees and others fought the fire, and every life was saved.

New York City Asylum for the Insane on Blackwell's Island

New York City Asylum for the Insane on Blackwell’s Island